=pod =head1 NAME Moose::Cookbook::Style - The latest in trendy Moose cuisine =for authors Please annotate all bad examples with comments so that they won't be copied by accident =cut =head1 Benefits of Good Style Good Moose style, as defined by this document, helps ensure your code has the following desirable properties: =over 4 =item Play well with others Your code will be more reusable and easier to extend. =item Ease maintenance The code will be easier to understand because it follows an accepted set of conventions and idioms. This will help others maintaining your code, and also help you to get support on IRC for instance. =item Help Moose generate better code By using the most appropriate features, the generated code will be safer and more efficient. =item Benefit from meta programming Code that operates on the metaclass will benefit from clean meta definitions. If you are manually converting argument types with C there is no meta data explaining your intention. If on the other hand you use coercions, there is introspectable meta data that makes this clear. This means that e.g. MooseX extensions that work by introspecting your class will be able to do the right thing more often, because they don't need to guess. =back =head1 Don't change C It is generally considered bad style to override L for a number of reasons. The first reason is consistency. Subclasses of your class and code instantiating your class would be simpler if your constructor works closer to the default. The second reason is performance. By calling C on your metaclass: __PACKAGE__->meta->make_immutable; And opting out of any class definition changes from that point on, you allow Moose to create more efficient versions of certain generic methods. Moose will generate a tight, optimal C for you, based on the minimal set of features you use. Moose provides many features that allow you to do common object construction tasks at the right level of abstraction. When attributes have the ability to provide the necessary functionality, use that. If that isn't sufficient, L has numerous features you can use at construction time. =head2 Use C instead of custom initialization or overriding C Instead of changing C, do initialization in C. The construction parameters are passed in, so you don't need to replicate C, and since C is called for each superclass that defines it, you will never forget to invoke your initializers if you extend them. =head2 Use C, C or C To initialize attributes there is a plethora of methods preferable to assigning the value at initialization time. If you want to translate parameter data, use coercions. If you want to ensure a parameter can't be overridden by the constructor, set the C to C instead of overwriting it in C. =head2 Use C to alter C<@_> processing If you need to change the way C<@_> is processed, for example for C<< Class->new( $single_param ) >>, use C instead of wrapping C. This ensures the behavior is subclassible, it keeps this logic independent of the other aspects of construction, and can be made efficient using C. =head1 Don't pollute the global type registry =head2 Use fully qualified type names for your own data L provides a convenient method to do this. If you define # Bad style: subtype Person => ( as 'Object', where { $_->can("name") }, ); Then the global name C is registered, and this could conflict with other bad usage of the sort. Instead, prefix type name with your project namespace, or class name: subtype 'My::Foo::Person' => ( as 'Object', where { $_->can("name") }, ); Or with L: use MooseX::Types::Moose qw(Object); use MooseX::Types ( -declare => [qw(Person)], ); subtype Person() => ( # note parenthesis, "Person" is a function, not a string as Object, # MooseX::Types::Moose exported it where { $_->can("name") }, ); =head3 Coerce in a subtype Likewise use fully qualified subtypes of other types for defining coercions, so that they won't affect unrelated code, causing action at a distance. This is important because the type registry is global, kind of like the symbol table. This means that code like: # Bad style: coerce ArrayRef => ( from Str => via { [ split /,/ ] }, ); Will add a coercion to B attributes like: has foo => ( isa => "ArrayRef", coerce => 1, ); when the actual coercion applies only to your specific cases. =head1 Clean up your package Use C or C to remove the sugar exports. This will make sure the sugar isn't accidentally called as methods on your objects. For instance: $obj->can("has"); will return true, even though C is not a method. If you choose L, make sure to keep the C method if you want to use it for introspection: use namespace::clean -except => "meta"; =head1 Accept no substitutes By substitutes I mean hacks instead of "proper" solutions. When you have a tricky requirement, refrain from abusing Moose or MooseX:: or whatever it is you are using. Instead, drop by IRC and discuss it. Most of the time a crazy idea can either be simplified, or it will spawn a clean, reliable feature to whatever package you are using. This will improve your code and also share the benefit with others. =head1 AUTHOR Yuval (nothingmuch) Kogman =head1 COPYRIGHT AND LICENSE Copyright 2006-2008 by Infinity Interactive, Inc. L This library is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the same terms as Perl itself. =cut